Skip to main content

A bug in Wolfram language Sum

Start form fresh kernel:

In[21]:= Quit[]

This is an indefinite Sum (see the documentation of Sum):

In[1]:= Sum[x[i],i]

Out[1]= Underscript[\[Sum], i]x[i]

In[2]:= Sum[Indexed[x,i],i]

Out[2]= Underscript[\[Sum], i]Subscript[x, i]

This evaluates wrongly:

In[3]:= Sum[_,i]

Out[3]= i _

and seems to break Sum:

In[4]:= Sum[y[i],i]

Out[4]= i _

In[5]:= Sum[Indexed[y,i],i]

Out[5]= i _

although all the sums that were previously evaluated are still correct:

In[6]:= Sum[x[i],i]

Out[6]= Underscript[\[Sum], i]x[i]

In[7]:= Sum[Indexed[x,i],i]

Out[7]= Underscript[\[Sum], i]Subscript[x, i]

Conclusions :

- Sum is broken by Sum[_,i],

- the kernel has some cache.

Indeed there is a cache and it can be cleared

In[8]:= ClearSystemCache[]

but this has no effect on Sum:

In[11]:= Sum[x[i],i]

Out[11]= Underscript[\[Sum], i]x[i]

In[12]:= Sum[y[i],i]

Out[12]= i _

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

If Mac OS X ssh with correct password does not work...

If this occurs to you, don't spend hours like me hacking /etc/ssh/sshd_config but check "All users" in System preferences > Sharing. Moreover, to apply the changes you must restart the server and you can do so quickly also in Sharing by checking out and in "Remote login". Indeed the behaviour is kind of buggy because you are still prompted for password and there is nothing to see in ssh -v. 
Post a Comment
Read more

Input cell numbering in Mathematica notebook

After some googling about cell numbering, I ended up being able to number inline formula, text, output, but not input cells. Of course, there is already the In[_] numbering or the possibility of numbering the corresponding output cell (if it exists), so that input cell numbering may not be necessary after all. However, when input is reevaluated, the In[_] numbering changes and the output cell numbering is lost so input cell numbering is really important. According to CounterTutorial.nb by P. J. Hinton, 1998: A CounterBox[ ] can appear only in a TextData[ ] expression of a cell, so that means you can use them only [in] cell styles associated with headings and body text.  They cannot be used in the contents of typeset math cells. Therefore, input cell numbering may not be so easy.  However: You can inspect the low level trickery that is used by opening up the notebook's style sheet and unformatting the prototype cell for NumberedEquation.  I won't go into too mu...
Post a Comment
Read more